Skip to main content

Mohammed Ali Shabbir

Shabbir Ali slams demonetisation on 10th anniversary, questions economic damage and unfulfilled promises – Mohammed Ali Shabbir

Shabbir Ali slams demonetisation on 10th anniversary, questions economic damage and unfulfilled promises

  • Congress leader says cash ban devastated livelihoods, small businesses, farmers and informal workers
  • Cites 99.3% return of banned notes, research on job losses and decline in agricultural trade
  • Questions economic gains despite Rs 7,965 crore currency printing expenditure in 2016-17

Hyderabad, November 7: Advisor to the Telangana Government and senior Congress leader Mohammed Ali Shabbir on Saturday strongly condemned the Narendra Modi government’s 2016 demonetisation decision, describing it as a disastrous economic experiment that inflicted enormous hardship on ordinary citizens, destroyed livelihoods and disrupted India’s cash-dependent informal economy without delivering adequately on its stated objectives.

Marking the tenth anniversary of demonetisation, Shabbir Ali said the sudden withdrawal of Rs 500 and Rs 1,000 currency notes on November 8, 2016, had invalidated nearly 87% of the country’s currency in circulation by value, triggering a severe cash shortage that affected millions of households, farmers, workers and small businesses.

“Ten years ago, Prime Minister Narendra Modi promised to eliminate black money, corruption, counterfeit currency and terror financing through demonetisation. People were asked to endure extraordinary hardships in the national interest. A decade later, the government has still not provided a comprehensive account of what the country actually gained from those sacrifices,” he said.

Shabbir Ali said the Reserve Bank of India’s final accounting had exposed serious questions about the effectiveness of demonetisation. According to RBI figures, approximately 99.3% of the invalidated currency, amounting to around Rs 15.31 lakh crore, returned to the banking system.

“The government presented demonetisation as a decisive strike against black money. But almost the entire value of the banned currency returned to banks. How much unaccounted income was ultimately detected? How much additional tax was recovered? How many counterfeit notes were eliminated? The government must answer these questions with verifiable figures,” he demanded.

The Congress leader said independent academic research had documented the economic disruption caused by the currency withdrawal. Referring to a study published in “The Quarterly Journal of Economics”, he noted that researchers estimated a reduction of at least two percentage points in employment and economic activity during the final quarter of 2016 compared with what would otherwise have been expected.

“This was not merely an inconvenience caused by standing in bank queues. It was an economic shock that affected employment, production, consumption and the ability of small businesses to survive. Daily-wage workers lost earnings, traders struggled to conduct business and thousands of cash-dependent enterprises faced severe uncertainty,” he said.

Shabbir Ali said agriculture had also suffered significantly. He referred to academic research indicating that agricultural market trade values declined by approximately 16% in the short run following demonetisation, with farmers facing difficulties in selling produce, purchasing inputs and paying agricultural labourers.

“Farmers were struggling to sell their harvests while agricultural workers were unable to receive wages. Small traders, vegetable vendors and rural households suffered because cash suddenly became unavailable. The government must explain why such widespread disruption was considered an acceptable price for a policy whose promised benefits remain disputed,” he said.

The Congress leader also questioned the financial costs of implementing demonetisation. He pointed out that expenditure on currency security printing across denominations reached approximately Rs 7,965 crore during July 2016–June 2017, reflecting the substantial administrative expense associated with currency replacement and regular printing operations.

Shabbir Ali further questioned the claim that demonetisation would permanently reduce dependence on cash. He said currency in circulation had increased from approximately Rs 17.77 lakh crore in November 2016 to more than Rs 43 lakh crore by October 2026.

“Digital payments have expanded considerably, but that cannot retrospectively justify the suffering caused by demonetisation. The growth of digital transactions and the continued expansion of currency in circulation show that India’s payment economy has evolved in multiple ways, not simply because high-value notes were withdrawn,” he said.

He said small traders, construction workers, agricultural labourers and self-employed families across Telangana had also faced serious difficulties during the cash shortage. “An economic decision must be judged by its actual results, not by political publicity. The hardships experienced by ordinary Indians cannot be dismissed merely because ten years have passed,” he said.

Shabbir Ali demanded that the Union Government release a comprehensive assessment of demonetisation, detailing its impact on employment, GDP, agriculture, small businesses, counterfeit currency, tax compliance and recovery of unaccounted income.

“November 8 should serve as a reminder that governments must remain accountable for decisions affecting millions of livelihoods. The people of India deserve transparent answers about the economic costs and measurable benefits of demonetisation,” he said. (eom)

Facebook
Pinterest
Twitter
LinkedIn

Comments are closed.